Exploring the debate on replacing modern CDs with vinyl reissues in the audiophile community.
Summary
- Is the dynamic range better on vinyl reissues than CDs?
- Quality varies based on mastering and original source.
- LP reissues can be a mixed bag in terms of sound quality.
- Consider collectibility and nostalgia in addition to sound quality.
Insightful Comments
sdmrdot suggests reissues may not always surpass original CDs due to the loudness war and compression, citing an example with Siamese Dream.
ChrisMag999 shares a video for further insight, highlighting the complexities of mastering in vinyl reissues.
Leboski emphasizes the importance of mastering quality and notes the benefits of vinyl reissues in certain cases such as The Mars Volta’s discography.
Jay-metal discusses the practicality of CDs over vinyl in terms of durability and cleanliness, advocating for sticking with CDs.
xidnpnlss advises seeking out first pressings for superior quality, raising concerns about reissues from digital sources.
The audiophile community presents diverse perspectives on the value of vinyl reissues versus modern CDs, highlighting the nuances of sound quality, mastering, and collectibility.